On this episode of The Sideline...
Episode overview
The first 2026 College Football Playoff rankings gave Mark, Zack and Scott a new question to work through: what should matter most when teams are separated by conference strength, head-to-head results, record and what they actually look like on the field? The guys build their own CFP top 12 from the bottom up, beginning with a consensus that Georgia belongs at No. 1 after dismantling Ole Miss. Utah follows at No. 2 after an unbeaten start and a Holy War performance that convinced all three hosts the Utes deserve more national attention. The agreement ends quickly. UCLA and defending national champion Indiana create the first real argument. Zack and Mark reward UCLA for remaining undefeated, while Scott believes Indiana has looked like the stronger team and would win a head-to-head matchup. That disagreement carries into the next tier. Alabama may have two losses, but the eye test tells Scott the Crimson Tide are one of the last teams anyone would want to face. Notre Dame and Miami force the table to decide how much their head-to-head result should matter, especially while Miami adjusts without Malachi Toney. Tennessee, Alabama and Texas create another test of consistency. Tennessee beat Alabama, Texas beat Tennessee and all three have shown enough talent to make a playoff run. The guys still agree that Texas has been carried more by its defense than by Arch Manning. They also question whether another loss could put Steve Sarkisian under serious pressure despite the money and expectations surrounding the program. The final spots bring BYU, Texas Tech, Kentucky, Ole Miss and Wake Forest into the discussion. Scott respects Texas Tech's record, while Mark questions whether its defense can survive a more physical opponent. Kentucky earns support because its two losses came against Alabama and Tennessee. Ole Miss remains Mark's most aggressive inclusion because he believes Trinidad Chambliss can recover from the pressure Georgia created. The episode closes with three college football locks. Scott takes SMU at home against Wake Forest, Zack backs Oklahoma State to upset Texas Tech and Mark predicts Northwestern will stay within the number against an Ohio State team he believes is falling apart.
Georgia and Utah Are the Clear Choices at the Top
Georgia takes the unanimous No. 1 spot after controlling Ole Miss on both sides of the ball. Utah lands at No. 2 because the Utes are undefeated and looked prepared for everything BYU tried in the Holy War. The real argument begins at No. 3. Mark and Zack reward UCLA for winning every game in front of it, while Scott believes defending champion Indiana has looked better and would beat UCLA on a neutral field.
Head-to-Head Results and the Eye Test Do Not Always Agree
Alabama, Tennessee, Notre Dame, Miami and Texas expose the problem with using one rule for every ranking. Alabama looks like one of the most dangerous teams in the country, but Tennessee beat the Crimson Tide. Notre Dame beat Miami, while Miami still looks more complete to Mark. Texas owns the win over Tennessee, yet the guys remain unconvinced by Arch Manning and believe the Longhorns defense is doing most of the work.
The Final CFP Spots Create Three Very Different Locks
BYU, Texas Tech, Kentucky and Ole Miss all receive support near the bottom of the top 12, but none escapes a major question. Texas Tech has the record but may not have the defense. Kentucky has two losses but both came against playoff-level SEC teams. Ole Miss has three losses, yet Mark still trusts Trinidad Chambliss. The episode ends with Scott taking SMU against Wake Forest, Zack backing Oklahoma State over Texas Tech and Mark predicting Northwestern covers against Ohio State.
Georgia and Utah Are the Clear Choices at the Top
Georgia takes the unanimous No. 1 spot after controlling Ole Miss on both sides of the ball. Utah lands at No. 2 because the Utes are undefeated and looked prepared for everything BYU tried in the Holy War. The real argument begins at No. 3. Mark and Zack reward UCLA for winning every game in front of it, while Scott believes defending champion Indiana has looked better and would beat UCLA on a neutral field.
Hosted by
Open this episode
Keep Exploring


